Several nights ago, I picked up the paideia program and started reading again for the first time in what seems like forever. The ideas are as compelling now as they were back when I was feeling the sting of a stifling educational environment--perhaps reinforced by my desire to shield my son from the pain that I suffered through. The Paideia proposal and program builds on the pedagogical philosophy of Dewey by delivering specific advice on pedagogical methods and content. I feel many of you would find the Paideia trilogy by Mortimer Adler to be of interest. Please check it out if you have any interest in applying the "great books" approach in education.
Showing posts with label Dewey. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dewey. Show all posts
Wednesday, March 16, 2011
The Paideia Program
I came across the paideia program about 10 years ago. When I first read it, I fell in love with the vision these educators painted. It strongly influenced my thoughts about what K-12 education should be and what the real purpose of education is--namely, to lead individuals in the pursuit of discovery about the world and, more importantly, self.
Friday, September 10, 2010
Prototype schools
A short list of folks we can contact at Dewey-oriented schools in the US:
1: John Dewey Learning Academy in Leecompton, KS, was founded nine years ago as an alternative high school.
Based in Kansas, but we might want to reach out by phone and email to get a sense of how these folks got started and what they are accomplishing.
"The mission of the John Dewey Learning Academy is to provide an authentic, nurturing, and academically challenging learning environment for high school level students that is connected to the world outside of school, is meaningful for students, and promotes their positive sense of community and enthusiasm for learning."
2: John Dewey High School in Brooklyn, NY, opened in September 1969. They list some interesting core principles:
* Students should learn by doing
* Students should learn at their own pace
* A student's education should be validated by his/her experience
* Grades inhibit learning and promote unwanted competition
* A classroom should be conducted by many teachers and many learners, not by one teacher and many learners
* If you give students responsibility, they will be responsible
* Students must be active participants in their education
3: The John Dewey Academy in Great Barrington, MA, just down the highway from Rachel and Greg in the Berkshires.
This one is a boarding high school for students ages 15-21. Their mission:
"We provide an individualized and comprehensive education for bright, troubled adolescents with a history of self-defeating or self-destructive choices. Our peer-based approach leads our students to high levels of achievement and inspires them to develop in ways that promote self-respect, maturity, and respect for others."
I found their FAQs helpful as a reality check as we continue to consider student needs when dealing with students with less privileged or less stable histories. Clinicians on board.
1: John Dewey Learning Academy in Leecompton, KS, was founded nine years ago as an alternative high school.
Based in Kansas, but we might want to reach out by phone and email to get a sense of how these folks got started and what they are accomplishing.
"The mission of the John Dewey Learning Academy is to provide an authentic, nurturing, and academically challenging learning environment for high school level students that is connected to the world outside of school, is meaningful for students, and promotes their positive sense of community and enthusiasm for learning."
2: John Dewey High School in Brooklyn, NY, opened in September 1969. They list some interesting core principles:
* Students should learn by doing
* Students should learn at their own pace
* A student's education should be validated by his/her experience
* Grades inhibit learning and promote unwanted competition
* A classroom should be conducted by many teachers and many learners, not by one teacher and many learners
* If you give students responsibility, they will be responsible
* Students must be active participants in their education
3: The John Dewey Academy in Great Barrington, MA, just down the highway from Rachel and Greg in the Berkshires.
This one is a boarding high school for students ages 15-21. Their mission:
"We provide an individualized and comprehensive education for bright, troubled adolescents with a history of self-defeating or self-destructive choices. Our peer-based approach leads our students to high levels of achievement and inspires them to develop in ways that promote self-respect, maturity, and respect for others."
I found their FAQs helpful as a reality check as we continue to consider student needs when dealing with students with less privileged or less stable histories. Clinicians on board.
Labels:
administration,
age,
boarding,
Dewey,
foster care,
mission,
networking
John Dewey Director of the Urban Education Institute
Someone to interview:
Dr. Timothy Knowles serves as John Dewey director of the University of Chicago Urban Education Institute (UEI). UEI is dedicated to addressing the question, how can we reliably produce excellent schooling for children growing up in urban America? UEI addresses this question in four ways: by undertaking rigorous applied research lead by the Consortium on Chicago School Research; developing urban teachers and leaders; operating and supporting PreK-12th grade schools; and designing scalable tools and ideas to improve teaching, learning and leadership.
During his tenure at the University of Chicago, UEI has initiated the creation of 20 new schools across Chicago’s south side, four of which are designed and operated directly by the University of Chicago. This portfolio of schools is designed to serve as an existence proof that poor children can learn at high levels. The schools also serve as a locus for developing new methodologies for training aspiring, new and veteran teachers and school leaders.
Prior to coming to Chicago, Knowles served as deputy superintendent for Teaching and Learning at the Boston Public Schools. While in Boston he created two organizations devoted to building the pipeline of high quality teachers and school leaders for Boston Public Schools and served as co-director of the Boston Annenberg Challenge, a nationally recognized effort to improve literacy instruction.
Prior to his work in Boston he founded and directed a full-service K-8 school in Bedford-Stuyvesant, New York City. He also served as the founding director of Teach for America in New York City, and a teacher of African History in Botswana.
He has written and spoken extensively on the topics of school leadership, teacher quality, school reform, and accountability in public schools.
He received his B.A. in anthropology and African history from Oberlin College and an M.A. and doctorate from the Harvard Graduate School of Education.
Contact info at the link above. I wonder if anyone at the Boston Foundation might put us in touch? I'm going to reach out today and see what happens.
Dr. Timothy Knowles serves as John Dewey director of the University of Chicago Urban Education Institute (UEI). UEI is dedicated to addressing the question, how can we reliably produce excellent schooling for children growing up in urban America? UEI addresses this question in four ways: by undertaking rigorous applied research lead by the Consortium on Chicago School Research; developing urban teachers and leaders; operating and supporting PreK-12th grade schools; and designing scalable tools and ideas to improve teaching, learning and leadership.
During his tenure at the University of Chicago, UEI has initiated the creation of 20 new schools across Chicago’s south side, four of which are designed and operated directly by the University of Chicago. This portfolio of schools is designed to serve as an existence proof that poor children can learn at high levels. The schools also serve as a locus for developing new methodologies for training aspiring, new and veteran teachers and school leaders.
Prior to coming to Chicago, Knowles served as deputy superintendent for Teaching and Learning at the Boston Public Schools. While in Boston he created two organizations devoted to building the pipeline of high quality teachers and school leaders for Boston Public Schools and served as co-director of the Boston Annenberg Challenge, a nationally recognized effort to improve literacy instruction.
Prior to his work in Boston he founded and directed a full-service K-8 school in Bedford-Stuyvesant, New York City. He also served as the founding director of Teach for America in New York City, and a teacher of African History in Botswana.
He has written and spoken extensively on the topics of school leadership, teacher quality, school reform, and accountability in public schools.
He received his B.A. in anthropology and African history from Oberlin College and an M.A. and doctorate from the Harvard Graduate School of Education.
Contact info at the link above. I wonder if anyone at the Boston Foundation might put us in touch? I'm going to reach out today and see what happens.
Monday, September 6, 2010
Thoughts on a Dewey school: student background edition
An "aha" moment getting at the thing I've been trying to pin down during our conversations -- what has us talking about disadvantaged/underprivileged students and boarding schools? Where is the emphasis on environmental factors coming from? What is it we're feeling the need to control for and/or eliminate entirely from students' lives 24/7?
In Experience and Education, John Dewey writes:
Dewey goes on to say that neither the traditional "battle of wills" method of bringing non-participating students into participation, nor the straight out exclusion of these students from the school, are solutions to these kinds of student situations. He also goes on to discuss the need for sufficiently thoughtful planning on the part of the school, so as to make room for and have resources to deal with such students.
But the assumption I'm hearing is that students start out wanting ever so much to learn and participate democratically and prepare ahead and strike the optimal balance of respect for authority and confidence in their individual positions. This I tend to agree with, but only within the context of students' developmental levels. There is likelihood of student disengagement, rebelliousness, passivity, and poor previous experience no matter where students come from in the socioeconomic spectrum. These things are part human variant, part developmental stage (like separation from authority in high school or devotion to black & white thinking and social group definition in middle school), and part -- not all - environment.
In our next conversation, or one of the next anyway, I'd like to chat more with the group about how, if at all, we would like to continue exploring the implications of targeting specifically disadvantaged student populations for any school endeavor. Ditto the boarding school. There's quite a bit students lose when they are removed from their home environment into one created by, and consisting solely of, their school environment. The kind of students we start talking about when we talk about the benefits of a boarding school will need much more infrastructural support than just a caring set of teachers and a dorm dad.
(Just having an anti-Stand and Deliver backlash moment, and wondering if we can talk about who we want to be as educators without creating straw orphans to save by the sheer power of our great teaching and school administration in the process.)
Have at it with me in the comments?
In Experience and Education, John Dewey writes:
"I am not romantic enough about the young to suppose that every pupil will respond or that any child of normally strong impulses will respond on every occasion. There are likely to be some who, when they come to school, are already victims of injurious conditions outside of the school and who have become so passive and unduly docile that they fail to contribute. There will be others who, because of previous experience, are bumptious and unruly and perhaps downright rebellious."
Dewey goes on to say that neither the traditional "battle of wills" method of bringing non-participating students into participation, nor the straight out exclusion of these students from the school, are solutions to these kinds of student situations. He also goes on to discuss the need for sufficiently thoughtful planning on the part of the school, so as to make room for and have resources to deal with such students.
But the assumption I'm hearing is that students start out wanting ever so much to learn and participate democratically and prepare ahead and strike the optimal balance of respect for authority and confidence in their individual positions. This I tend to agree with, but only within the context of students' developmental levels. There is likelihood of student disengagement, rebelliousness, passivity, and poor previous experience no matter where students come from in the socioeconomic spectrum. These things are part human variant, part developmental stage (like separation from authority in high school or devotion to black & white thinking and social group definition in middle school), and part -- not all - environment.
In our next conversation, or one of the next anyway, I'd like to chat more with the group about how, if at all, we would like to continue exploring the implications of targeting specifically disadvantaged student populations for any school endeavor. Ditto the boarding school. There's quite a bit students lose when they are removed from their home environment into one created by, and consisting solely of, their school environment. The kind of students we start talking about when we talk about the benefits of a boarding school will need much more infrastructural support than just a caring set of teachers and a dorm dad.
(Just having an anti-Stand and Deliver backlash moment, and wondering if we can talk about who we want to be as educators without creating straw orphans to save by the sheer power of our great teaching and school administration in the process.)
Have at it with me in the comments?
Monday, August 30, 2010
Ideal School
What does the ideal school look and feel like?
Rachel: Ideal school - students feel beloved in their school. Have relationships in the school (teachers, parents, other students). Less transactional, more community focus. Picturing an elementary school. What are ages, etc? Class sizes? Ability to explore having groups of students stay with one teacher. Schoolhouse model. As opposed to graded system with different teachers. Keep teachers with students for more years, so students know class etc along the way. Amalgam of montessori and home school.
Rachel: Ideal school - students feel beloved in their school. Have relationships in the school (teachers, parents, other students). Less transactional, more community focus. Picturing an elementary school. What are ages, etc? Class sizes? Ability to explore having groups of students stay with one teacher. Schoolhouse model. As opposed to graded system with different teachers. Keep teachers with students for more years, so students know class etc along the way. Amalgam of montessori and home school.
- Phil: About age groups. If a boarding school, what can we get? If we can get at kindergarten, then let's do it. Get them educated as early as can. Small ratio, community orientation, "communing" with other students. Multiple years of teachers, good. Like to talk about the role of the teacher in the classroom. The role of teacher is dependent on the philosophy. If it's to inculcate the habit of learning, teacher is a guide not a sage. Teacher is not an authority figure. Students must take an active part in their own education. Allows students to excel in their own interests. Inquiry based education as opposed to graded content system.
Phil: Our school: interest based, engaged education -- without the Montessori guide-less model. More structured than Montessori, less structured than PS 89.
- Waldorf - a viable alternative school system based on anthroposophy
John: going back to community -- you have a school where kids are excited about being there, eventually the students will be involved in tutoring, teaching, engaging other students in projects, meal prep, working together as a team -- the culture develops as a side effect of the structure.
PB - a well run school is like a happy family.
Rachel: I know of a school in New Hampshire that does interesting things despite demographics, like immersion Chinese, cricket, etc.
Phil: I'm committed to making a new school, not copying an existing one. Don't know of any school based on Deweyian education. Is about being a good person and citizen as well as knowledge gains. Don't know about you, but education system did not prepare me for real life.
Tessie: How to fix a flat, plunge toilet, change an electrical fixture.
Rachel: Some of that is luck of the draw. Not everybody gets the parents that will teach you this kind of thing.
John: These kids can grow up to be that kind of parent.
- Greg: One of teh things we could do for math education is to focus on using the computational tools we have -- instead of teaching students how to do the integral, teach them how they can use modeling an integral (using a real world problem) and then have computational tools to do teh integration, then analyze results.Any real world math problem breaks into : understanding, modeling, solving, and analyzing. We currently teach step 3. Dewey's steps: admitting/recognizing problem; hypothesize; test; revisit as necessary. Ties heavily into inquiry-based education
Jess: Other than the anthroposophy influence, I've been very impressed by the Waldorf model. There are a lot of good parts to each educational system. We should see what bits work and what bits do not and go from there. No point reinventing the wheel.
Jess: My greatest hope is that we can find a way to have a school that I would be proud for my child to attend with few if any reservations.
[These were our initial comments on the subject.]
SUMMARY: We want a well-rounded educational system that does not just teach facts but also instills an awareness of the environment and community, as well as enabling students to develop executive function skills. They will become knowledgeable, practical, wise, compassionate, and nurturing individuals if we succeed.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)